Macrolog
On Selling Out
On Kottke’s weblog today, there’s a post comparing manufactured pseudo-punk Avril Lavigne to her supposedly less phony pop-punk genremates, with a link to an interesting rant by Dave Eggers about ‘selling out’.
The Eggers rant is interesting, yes, but also lazy. Isn’t it just playing into the hands of the puritans and the naysayers?
Personally, I’ve always taken the term ‘selling out’ to mean compromising one’s artistic integrity for the sake of popularity and/or financial profit. By this reasoning, therefore, just because one becomes famous and makes a lot of money from one’s art does not necessitate that one is a sell-out.
Regarding the Avril Lavigne thing however, and the obvious attempt to show that the line between ‘real’ and ‘phony’ is blurry at best — well let me give you another example:
Some time last year, Puddle of Mudd were guests on a BBC music show called Re:Covered, where bands play two songs to a live studio audience; one an original piece, the other a cover. Puddle of Mudd began with a cover of an old Alice In Chains song, Brother. It was a stunning rendition, beautifully performed, resonating with emotion. Alice In Chains were obviously an inspiration to them, and it showed.
Then they played one of their own songs. And they were fucking awful.
I guess the moral of this story is, just because you can play a song well doesn’t mean you’re any more ‘real’, or any less ‘phony’. If music is more important to you than the superficial appreciation of a well-played tune, the differences do matter.
Mon 21 Apr 2003 at 19:21 ·
Comments (6 responses)
Comments are closed or not available for this entry. If you still wish to make a comment you can , citing this entry in the subject line.
Posted by Dave R
Mon 21 Apr 2003
at 22:37
Hey dude…I dunno if you know, but, the writing is right up against the left hand side of the screen - doesnt really look right, looks like that on my puter anyway, later,
Hmm… your browser must not be able to handle the style sheet. It’s working fine in IE 5 for the Mac, as well as Camino. Blame the browser makers for not ahering to web standards.
Posted by dg
Tue 22 Apr 2003
at 03:51
Yeah, in my Fake PC Windoze IE, it’s all on the left. Looks gorgeous on my Mac though so who cares.
Posted by eoin
Tue 22 Apr 2003
at 15:45
perhaps it would be wise to change it though, since the vast majority of people surfing the net use the pc version of IE, and know feck all about web standards, and will think it’s all your fault
About
This is the personal website of MacDara Conroy, a twenty-something journalist, editor and all-round creative type living in Dublin, Ireland.
Read more.
Details
You are reading On Selling Out, a Macrolog entry by MacDara Conroy. It is filed under Music, and was published in April 2003.
Tags: (This page has not yet been tagged.)
Continuum
↑ Thu 24 Apr 2003 at 18:20
→ Mon 21 Apr 2003 at 19:21
↓ Fri 18 Apr 2003 at 18:13